Your expectations need to be tempered based upon, a, the history of the program you support and, b, the level of support it gets from the community. We are WAY behind both Dayton and vcu in both metrics.
Even before vcu's Final Four season, they had been to the tournament 9 times, and had been a #2 seed (in 1985). Right now, they are averaging almost double our attendance and are raising about three times as much money per season in donations.
Dayton has been to the NCAA tournament 18 times, the Sweet 16 7, the Elite 8 3, and the Final Four once. They play in a 14,000 seat arena where they consistently average 12,000 a game. They spend over $5 million a year on basketball.
Larranaga is the most successful coach in our program's history and he went to 5 NCAA tournaments in 14 seasons here. Do you know what we got in donations the year we went to the Final Four? It was under $100,000. The most we've ever averaged per game in attendance is 6,800. The most we've ever received in donations is $1.2 million.
You take a look at the other schools who made the leap: Wichita State, Creighton, Butler you will see the same thing: a program with great fan support before, and a history of basketball excellence even before the leap. Gonzaga is the only outlier here and they were lucky to be in a conference where they could dominate everyone for years before St. Mary's finally got good. I don't consider Davidson in this group, because they look more like us than they do these other teams.
Right now, we've got to give Paulsen the space to put the infrastructure in place for sustained success. What Larranaga built here was based solely on his coaching ability. He didn't have the support he needed or deserved either from the university or the community.