I'd be fine with Claxton or Tony. But if CKE leaves for Providence it's on Dr. W, who had to have known what he was getting into when he hired CKE. Didn't Washington say something about putting the A10 on notice with CKE's hire?
To throw up your hands after two years and say, "We can't afford to match P5 salaries" is weak. Because if that is the case (and it may be) you don't hire a guy with CKE's profile to begin with. You just wind up left at the alter with egg on your face.
If CKE is gone by this evening IMO we need to announce hire Tony's (or Speedy's) hiring by the end of the week. The great thing with getting behind Tony is his connection to the program. That mutual affinity cannot be underestimated and will serve us well when Skinn starts having success, as I think he will.
One last point: If CKE indeed leaves after just two years, I don't EVER want to entertain the prospect of hiring a young, nationally well-regarded coach with a profile like English, since we are clearly not willing, nor capable of, doing what it takes to keep them.