Bucknell is a good school, but it’s a liberal arts school and Mason is a research 1 institution. They aren’t the same thing. That’s not necessarily an advantage Bucknell (in other words, not the same thing as a recruit choosing W&M or an Ivy for their academics over us).
As it relates to competing at the top of the conference, sure, but one loss in March means good-bye NCAA (see: this season as an example). So who cares? It’s this precise reason that Davidson moved up (Steph Curry’s post-Elite Eight season really stuck with McKillops for a long time.
As for not beating good teams consistently, this is true, but we haven’t had a complete team yet. This year we thought we did, but Otis regressed, Mar massively regressed, Grayer was either hurt or didn’t want to be here anymore, and Reuter turned out to be not the player we thought he was. Then Boyd hurts his shooting wrist in the middle of the reason right when we were figuring things out. Result: some losses we really shouldn’t have had.
Even though next season is going to be tough in a tougher A10, especially without Otis, if no one critical leaves and we don’t have any major injuries, I actually think we will finally have a consistent team. Will that mean winning the A10? Probably not. But I bet we finish with a better RPI next year.