I'll be the turd in the punch bowl. I understand the skepticism more than I see the hype.
First, I agree the bench will be a lot better this year, but "how good is your best five?" is probably the most important question. I'm not sure we got better - Schwartz was fantastic last year and it seems optimistic to assume VBJ is just going to replace his production.
Second, there is a ton riding on Saquan being the answer at the point. If he's not, the season gets hairy real quick. I hope he comes in and kills it but I won't exactly be surprised if he struggles.
We know what we're getting with Oduro, Ticket, and Coop, and hopefully the latter two don't turn into zeroes down the stretch again. We will be deeper, and we should be better defensively. I don't know how much offensive firepower we'll have since we'll need these transfers to be the best versions of themselves, rather than the versions that actually played last year.
I'm trying to think through the range of outcomes - seems like we have a decently high floor, but it's also tough to see top 4 upside. Best case scenario, Saquan is a passable point that can slash and put pressure on the rim, we get tons of shooting from Coop/Ticket/VBJ, Oduro dominates again, the bench is lively and we don't enter a late season tailspin. It's tough to see how that puts Mason in the top 3 of Dayton/ SLU/vcu, and a lot would need to go right with the other A10 schools for that to finish 4th.
There's also a worst case scenario where point guard is an issue all year, Kim moving Oduro to the perimeter to help him prep for the next level is a disaster, and VBJ never regains his form. One or more of those things going wrong almost seems more likely to me than the upside scenario.
Hope very much I'm wrong about this, but I also think a number of A10 teams will be improved, so the conference will be as tough as it has been in a while.