I wrote about this but parents and players read the stuff we post so I soft-pedaled a little bit. Recruiting has SUCKED for like four years now and is somehow getting worse. Do people realize how bad the offer sheets were for everyone from the Hartwell class on down? Do they realize how many players the staff brought in (Haidara, Gadsden, debatably more) that had zero other executable D1 offers? That's MEAC level incompetence on the trail. Whoever comes next is going to look like a freaking wizard in recruiting after the Paulsen era.
I'd say it's been more of a mixed bag with players like Kolek and Gray on the high end and Gadsden and Dady on the low end.
I'm not sure quite sure how to read Frazier or Henry's offer sheets (like would you consider LA Tech, Oral Roberts [now that they're in the Sweet 16], Murray State, and Southern Illinois as good mid-major offers for Henry? Do you count UMass's 2019 offer to Frazier? Was that still a viable scholarship when he took a prep year?)
XJ and Polite are in a class all on their own, because it's pretty obvious they were good to great high school players who just didn't get a lot of offers (similar to Jordan Miller who, like Polite, was all-met first team).
If you take a sweep at the entire 7 recruiting classes you've only got a handful of players in all of that time who had A-10/P5 level offers: AJ, Mar, Calixte, Kolek, Frazier, Gray (I was able to name them all off the top of my head).
If you've got a bunch of Koleks on your team, then the occasional "we think this guy is being underrecruited -- Jordan, Oduro, Otis, Grayer, Polite" makes sense. Those guys might blow up and if not they either transfer or become practice players at then end of your bench. It's also not the end of the world when you get a guy like Goanar (who had offers from Nebraska, Iowa State, and DePaul, and he doesn't work out [think Jermaine Harris at URI], because you've got a bunch of Koleks on your team killing it.